Bedsharing parents and advocates are under assault in Fort Wayne, Indiana, as local officials attempt to censor safe bedsharing guidelines from the public.
The conflict began in July 2009, when the Indiana Department of Child Services launched an anti-cosleeping “safe sleep campaign” with a disturbing and emotionally confrontational PSA depicting a mother and baby sleeping on a sofa, only to discover upon waking that the infant was not breathing. Following the disturbing images was the printed message “Never sleep with an infant”. In addition to the PSA, DCS has also devoted a page of their website to the campaign, which contains a variety of links to anti-cosleeping articles as well as a banner in the middle of their home page stating that “1 to 2 children in Indiana die each week due to bedsharing”. (To view the PSA, click here:
http://www.in.gov/dcs/files/Clip2(1).wmv)
In response to the heavily biased campaign launched by the state, Birth Matters, a Fort Wayne childbirth and family education center, has been working to present balanced information about safe sleep to the public. In October, Birth Matters will host a Safe Infant Sleep Symposium, which will present guidelines for safe infant sleep in cribs, bassinets, co-sleepers, and parents’ beds.
The goal of the symposium is to provide families and care providers with balanced, research-based, up-to-date information about safe infant sleep, and to support families’ rights to make informed, safe choices regarding how and where their children sleep.
The Symposium has drawn criticism from Fort Wayne authorities who say that the only message families should be given is “Never sleep with an infant”.
In an effort to work together with community leaders, Hallie Greider and Jordan Saalfrank, co-founders of Birth Matters, met with officials to discuss the symposium, and to personally extend invitations. Despite a large, growing body of research-based evidence for safe bedsharing, supported by the World Health Organization, UNICEF, and La Leche League International, among others, officials declined to attend the symposium, stating that there was no legitimate evidence to support bedsharing as a safe infant sleep option.
Officials also presented Birth Matters with a discussion about 13 infant death cases in Allen County which were caused by unsafe sleep conditions, and suggested that providing the public with safe bedsharing guidelines could cause additional deaths. However, when requested, Greider and Saalfrank were denied access to investigation records regarding the deaths.
“The public should have the right to know under what circumstances those babies died. It seems incredibly unlikely to me that many, if any, of those babies were bedsharing within the safe bedsharing guidelines. In fact, during the course of the conversation we had that day, I learned that one of the infants in question died in bed with 9 other children, another was sleeping improperly strapped into a car seat, and several were sleeping on sofas. To say that educating the public about safe bedsharing guidelines will exacerbate the problem just seems ridiculous; none of those situations are representative of safe bedsharing,” says Greider.
Saalfrank has additional concerns: “It’s not bedsharing itself that is dangerous, it’s bedsharing outside of the safe bedsharing guidelines that is dangerous. If families can’t implement those guidelines because they don’t have access to them, every baby sleeping with a parent is at risk. The reality we’re faced with is that elected officials are putting infants in our community at risk by choosing to remain ignorant of what research-based evidence is telling us.”
While officials in Fort Wayne continue to push an anti-cosleeping agenda, Birth Matters recognizes that no single sleep solution will work for every family. The upcoming symposium will provide safe sleep guidelines for a variety of different sleep situations in order to empower families, no matter where their infants sleep. “We’re not advocating for families to bedshare; we’re advocating for families to have the right to full information about safe sleep, which includes safe bedsharing guidelines,” says Greider.
The Safe Infant Sleep Symposium will take place October 2, 2010 at the Fort Wayne War Memorial Coliseum. Speakers include Dr. Christopher Tallo, Fort Wayne Pediatrician; Dr. Robert White, Indiana Neonatologist; and Dr. James McKenna, Director of the Mother-Baby Behavioral Sleep Laboratory at the University of Notre Dame, Chair of Notre Dame’s Department of Anthropology, member of the SIDS Global Task Force, and consultant to the American Academy of Pediatrics’ Committee on Safe Infant Sleep. Admission is free. For more information, or to contribute to the cause, visit www.safesleepindiana.org
Birth Matters was founded in 2008 by Hallie Greider (certified childbirth educator, certified doula) and Jordan Saalfrank (MSW, certified doula) to provide comprehensive education and support for families through pregnancy, childbirth, and the transition to parenting. For more information, visit www.birthmatters.com
(written by Heather Puff September 2010)